The Coffee Chat Playbook: How to Turn 30 Minutes Into a Job Offer

Nobody gets hired from a coffee chat. That's not how it works.

What happens is this: you have a good coffee chat. They remember you. They introduce you to someone else. You stay in touch. When an opportunity arises, your name comes up. The chat didn't get you the job. But it started the chain of events that did.

This is the game. Coffee chats are relationship-building, not job-hunting. The best networkers understand this. They play the long game.

This guide covers how to turn 30-minute conversations into relationships that actually lead somewhere.

---

The Purpose of Coffee Chats

What You're Actually Doing

A coffee chat is not:

• A job interview
• A pitch session for yourself
• An opportunity to ask for a job
• A one-time transaction

A coffee chat is:

• Relationship building
• Information gathering
• Learning about someone's path
• Creating a connection that can develop over time

The Two Goals

Every coffee chat should achieve two things:

Goal 1: Learn something valuable

• About their career path
• About their firm or industry
• About how to navigate your own path

Goal 2: Make a positive impression

• So they remember you
• So they'd be willing to help again
• So they might introduce you to others

If you achieve both, the chat succeeded. Results come later.

---

Before the Chat

Getting the Meeting

The cold outreach formula:

1. Personal connection (if any): Alumni, mutual connection, shared background
2. Specific reason for them: Why this person, not just anyone
3. Clear ask: 15-20 minutes for a call or coffee
4. Easy out: Acknowledge they're busy

Example:

"Hi [Name],

I'm a junior at [University] studying finance, and I came across your profile through [connection/research]. Your path from [their background] to [current role] really resonated with me, particularly [specific aspect].

I'd love to hear about your experience at [Firm] and any advice you might have. Would you have 15-20 minutes for a call in the coming weeks? I know you're busy, so no worries if the timing doesn't work.

Thanks for considering, [Your name]"

Researching the Person

Before any chat, know:

Their background:

• Where did they go to school?
• What was their career path?
• How long have they been at current firm?

Their current role:

• What group/team are they in?
• What kind of work do they do?
• Any recent deals or projects?

Common ground:

• Shared schools, activities, or interests
• People you both know
• Similar backgrounds or experiences

Preparing Questions

Have questions ready, but don't read from a script.

Good categories:

Career path questions:

• What attracted you to [firm/industry]?
• How did you decide between [options]?
• What was the transition from X to Y like?

Role-specific questions:

• What does a typical week look like?
• What types of deals/projects do you work on?
• What do you like most/least about the role?

Advice questions:

• What do you wish you'd known when starting out?
• What separates people who succeed from those who don't?
• What would you recommend for someone in my position?

Industry questions:

• How is [trend] affecting your work?
• What changes do you expect in the next few years?
• What should someone interested in this space be learning?

---

During the Chat

The First Two Minutes

First impressions happen fast. Get these right:

Arrive prepared:

• On time (or 2 minutes early)
• Professionally dressed (match their context)
• Phone away, attention fully present

Open warmly:

• Thank them for their time
• Brief personal connection if relevant
• Quick context on why you reached out

Set the frame:

• "I'd love to hear about your path and get any advice you have"
• Shows respect for their time and expertise

The Flow of Conversation

A good coffee chat follows a natural arc:

Minutes 0-5: Warm-up

• Light conversation
• Establish rapport
• Their current situation

Minutes 5-20: Their story

• Career path and decisions
• What they've learned
• Their perspective on the industry

Minutes 20-25: Your situation

• Brief overview of your background
• Where you're trying to go
• Specific questions or challenges

Minutes 25-30: Closing

• Key takeaways
• Next steps
• Gratitude

What to Talk About

Let them talk more than you. Aim for 70/30 or 60/40 in their favor.

Ask follow-up questions. Shows you're listening, not just waiting to talk.

Be genuinely curious. People can tell the difference.

Share when relevant. Brief personal context helps them give better advice.

What Not to Do

Don't ask for a job directly. It's awkward and ineffective.

Don't dominate the conversation. This is about them, not you.

Don't be negative. About your current situation, past employers, or others.

Don't be unprepared. Asking things you could Google is disrespectful.

Don't overstay. If they gave you 30 minutes, wrap up at 25-30.

Reading the Room

Pay attention to signals:

They're engaged:

• Asking you questions
• Offering specifics and advice
• Suggesting people to meet

They're rushing:

• Short answers
• Checking phone or watch
• Not asking follow-up questions

Adjust accordingly. If they're engaged, you can extend. If they're rushing, wrap up gracefully.

---

Ending Well

The Strong Finish

Summarize value: "This has been incredibly helpful. I really appreciate your perspective on [specific thing]."

Specific ask (if appropriate): "Is there anyone else you'd recommend I speak with?"

Clear next step: "Would it be okay if I followed up in a few months as recruiting approaches?"

Genuine gratitude: "Thank you so much for taking the time. I know you're busy."

The Ask for Referrals

This is the highest-value outcome of a good chat.

When they offer: "Is there anyone else you'd suggest I talk to?"

• Accept enthusiastically
• Ask if you can mention their name
• Follow up promptly

When they don't offer:

• You can ask: "Are there others you'd recommend I speak with?"
• Don't push if they hesitate
• One referral per chat is plenty

Getting Their Contact

If they haven't given it: "Would it be okay if I stayed in touch by email?"

Most will give you their contact. If they don't, respect it.

---

After the Chat

The Thank-You Note

Send within 24 hours. Email is fine.

Structure:

1. Thank them for their time
2. Reference something specific from the conversation
3. Reiterate any next steps
4. Brief, not long-winded

Example:

"Hi [Name],

Thank you so much for taking the time to meet with me today. Your perspective on [specific topic] was really valuable, especially [specific insight].

I'll definitely [follow up on their advice—e.g., look into that program, reach out to Sarah]. Thanks again for offering to connect me with [referral name]—I'll reach out to them this week and mention your name.

Hope to stay in touch, and best of luck with [something they mentioned].

Best, [Your name]"

Following Up on Referrals

If they gave you names:

Reach out promptly (within a week)

Mention the connection: "Sarah suggested I reach out—she mentioned you'd have great perspective on..."

Update the original contact: "Just wanted to let you know I reached out to [referral]. Thanks again for the introduction."

Staying in Touch

The relationship doesn't end with one chat.

Legitimate reasons to reach out:

• Update on your progress: "I just accepted an offer at Goldman—wanted to thank you for your advice during recruiting"
• Relevant news: "Saw your firm announced [deal]—congratulations"
• Asking advice on a decision: Brief, specific questions
• Annual check-in: Around recruiting season or major milestones

What not to do:

• Constant emails with no purpose
• Asking for favors too frequently
• Only reaching out when you need something

---

Advanced Strategies

Building a Networking System

Track your contacts:

• Name, firm, how you connected
• Date of last contact
• Key things you discussed
• Follow-up needed

Set reminders:

• Follow up with key contacts every 3-6 months
• More frequently during active recruiting

Quality over quantity:

• 20 strong relationships beat 100 weak ones
• Focus on people who engage with you

Converting Relationships to Opportunities

The long game:

1. Initial chat → positive impression
2. Follow-up → stay on their radar
3. Multiple touchpoints → genuine relationship
4. Opportunity arises → they think of you
5. Internal referral → interview access

This takes time. Relationships that lead to jobs often develop over 6-18 months.

Handling Senior People

Senior professionals (VPs, MDs, partners) require adjusted approach:

Be even more concise. Their time is more valuable.

Do more research. They'll notice if you haven't.

Ask about their perspective. They have unique vantage points.

Don't ask basic questions. Save those for junior people.

Follow up appropriately. Less frequently, more substantively.

Networking Across Functions

Connect with people beyond your target role:

HR/recruiting: Understand the process from inside

Adjacent roles: Learn about related opportunities

Industry contacts: Understand the business side

Alumni: Often most willing to help

---

Common Mistakes

Before the Chat

Sending generic outreach: Personalize every message

Not researching: Know who you're talking to

Asking for too much time: 15-20 minutes, not an hour

Poor timing: Don't reach out during deal closings or bonus season

During the Chat

Talking too much about yourself: Let them share

Asking for a job: Never directly in a coffee chat

Being unprepared: Have questions ready

Not listening: Actually engage with their answers

Overstaying: Respect the time they gave you

After the Chat

Not following up: Always send a thank-you note

Waiting too long: Follow up within 24 hours

Empty follow-ups: Have substance when you reach out

Over-following-up: Don't be annoying

Forgetting referrals: If they gave names, use them

---

The Mindset Shift

From Transaction to Relationship

Bad networkers think: "How do I get something from this person?"

Good networkers think: "How do I build a relationship with this person?"

The irony: relationship-focused networking leads to better outcomes than transactional networking. People help people they like and respect.

From Ask to Offer

Look for ways to provide value:

Share relevant information: Article, insight, connection they might find useful

Be helpful: If you can assist with something, offer

Show appreciation: Genuine gratitude matters

Make introductions: Once you have your own network

From Short-Term to Long-Term

Most people network only when they need something. This is obvious and off-putting.

Better approach:

• Network consistently, not just during recruiting
• Stay in touch during good times, not just when asking for help
• Think in years, not weeks

---

The Bottom Line

Coffee chats don't get you jobs directly. They build relationships that eventually lead to opportunities. The people who succeed at networking understand this.

The formula:

1. Get the meeting (personalized, specific outreach)
2. Have a great conversation (let them talk, be genuinely curious)
3. End well (specific takeaways, ask for referrals)
4. Follow up (thank-you note, action on referrals)
5. Stay in touch (periodic, substantive contact)
6. Repeat (with new people and existing contacts)

The mindset:

• Relationships over transactions
• Long-term over short-term
• Giving over asking
• Genuine curiosity over performance

Play the long game. Build real relationships. The opportunities will follow.

Thirty minutes at a time.