Finance Across Cities: Comparing Careers in New York, San Francisco, London, and Hong Kong
Where you work shapes your finance career in ways that go beyond salary. Here's an honest comparison of New York, San Francisco, London, and Hong Kong—the opportunities, lifestyle trade-offs, and what each city offers.
Finance Across Cities: Comparing Careers in New York, San Francisco, London, and Hong Kong
The Goldman Sachs analyst in New York makes $200K and lives in a 500 square foot apartment. The same role in San Francisco pays similarly but offers access to the tech ecosystem. London offers lower pay but more vacation. Hong Kong has great tax rates but uncertain political dynamics.
Same job. Different lives.
Where you build your finance career matters beyond the role itself. The city shapes your opportunities, your lifestyle, your network, and your long-term trajectory.
Here's an honest comparison of the four major global finance hubs—what each offers, what each costs, and how to think about where to build your career.
New York: The Financial Capital
The Opportunity
New York remains the global center of finance. More jobs, more firms, more deal flow than anywhere else.
What you get:
- Deepest job market across all finance verticals
- Headquarters of most major banks and many PE/HF firms
- Highest deal volume and largest transactions
- Maximum optionality for exits and career pivots
- Unmatched networking density
Key industries:
- Investment banking (all sectors)
- Private equity (all strategies)
- Hedge funds (all strategies)
- Asset management
- Everything else
The concentration: If it happens in finance, it happens in New York. No other city offers comparable depth.
The Lifestyle
Compensation: Highest absolute pay globally. First-year banking analysts earn $200-240K total comp.
Cost of living: Among the highest globally. A decent one-bedroom apartment costs $3,500-5,000/month in Manhattan.
| Expense | Monthly Cost |
|---|---|
| 1BR apartment (Manhattan) | $3,500-5,000 |
| 1BR apartment (Brooklyn/Queens) | $2,500-3,500 |
| Dining/entertainment | $500-1,500 |
| Transportation | $150-300 |
Work culture: Long hours are normalized. Face time matters. The culture is intense, competitive, and driven.
Quality of life: World-class dining, arts, entertainment. But small living spaces, crowded commutes, and limited nature access.
The Trade-offs
Pros:
- Maximum career optionality
- Highest compensation
- Deepest professional network
- Cultural and social richness
Cons:
- Highest cost of living
- Most intense work culture
- Small living spaces
- Brutal winters, hot summers
San Francisco: The Tech-Finance Hybrid
The Opportunity
San Francisco bridges finance and technology. It's where tech meets capital.
What you get:
- Premier access to technology sector
- Venture capital concentration
- Tech-focused PE and growth equity
- Technology investment banking
- Fintech ecosystem
Key industries:
- Venture capital
- Growth equity
- Tech investment banking
- Hedge funds (tech-focused)
- Fintech and crypto
The niche: If you want finance exposure to technology, San Francisco is unmatched. But traditional finance is more limited than New York.
The Lifestyle
Compensation: Similar to New York for equivalent roles. Slightly lower in some traditional finance roles.
Cost of living: Comparable to New York, arguably higher for equivalent space.
| Expense | Monthly Cost |
|---|---|
| 1BR apartment (SF proper) | $3,000-4,500 |
| 1BR apartment (East Bay) | $2,200-3,200 |
| Dining/entertainment | $500-1,200 |
| Transportation | $200-400 (car often needed) |
Work culture: More casual than New York. Tech influence creates different norms—more flexibility but still demanding hours.
Quality of life: Outstanding weather. Access to nature (hiking, wine country, beaches). But homelessness, urban challenges, and commute issues are real.
The Trade-offs
Pros:
- Tech ecosystem access
- Better weather and nature
- More casual culture
- Innovation proximity
Cons:
- Narrower finance job market
- Lower traditional finance presence
- High cost of living
- Car often necessary
London: The European Hub
The Opportunity
London is the gateway to Europe and a global finance center with distinct character.
What you get:
- European finance hub
- Strong investment banking presence
- Growing private equity scene
- Access to EMEA deal flow
- International diversity
Key industries:
- Investment banking (EMEA coverage)
- Private equity (Europe-focused)
- Hedge funds (macro, systematic)
- Asset management
- Sales and trading (particularly FX, rates)
The positioning: London offers global careers with European lifestyle. Strong for EMEA roles, less central for Americas-focused work.
The Lifestyle
Compensation: Lower than New York in absolute terms. First-year analysts earn £70-80K base plus £40-60K bonus (~$130-180K total).
Cost of living: High but more varied than NYC. More options for different price points.
| Expense | Monthly Cost |
|---|---|
| 1BR apartment (Central) | £2,000-3,000 ($2,500-3,800) |
| 1BR apartment (Zone 2-3) | £1,400-2,000 ($1,800-2,500) |
| Dining/entertainment | £400-800 ($500-1,000) |
| Transportation | £150-200 ($190-250) |
Work culture: Still demanding but more boundaries than NYC. More vacation actually used. Less face time culture.
Quality of life: Excellent cultural scene. Easier European travel. But gray weather, higher taxes, and Brexit-related uncertainty.
The Trade-offs
Pros:
- Better work-life balance than NYC
- European lifestyle and travel
- International exposure
- Historic, cultural city
Cons:
- Lower absolute compensation
- Higher taxes
- Weather challenges
- Brexit uncertainty for some roles
Hong Kong: The Asia Gateway
The Opportunity
Hong Kong connects global finance to Greater China and Asia.
What you get:
- Gateway to Chinese markets
- Asia-Pacific deal flow
- Strong IB and PE presence
- Growing hedge fund presence
- Tax-efficient location
Key industries:
- Investment banking (Asia coverage)
- Private equity (Asia-focused)
- Hedge funds
- Asset management
- China capital markets
The positioning: Essential for Asia-focused careers. Less relevant for Americas or Europe focus.
The Lifestyle
Compensation: Comparable to New York for equivalent roles, sometimes higher given tax efficiency.
Cost of living: Extremely high real estate costs. Among the most expensive housing globally.
| Expense | Monthly Cost |
|---|---|
| 1BR apartment (Central/Mid-Levels) | HK$25,000-40,000 ($3,200-5,100) |
| 1BR apartment (outer areas) | HK$15,000-22,000 ($1,900-2,800) |
| Dining | HK$5,000-10,000 ($640-1,300) |
| Transportation | HK$1,000-1,500 ($130-190) |
Tax advantage: Hong Kong's low, simple tax system (~15% effective) significantly increases after-tax income.
Work culture: Demanding hours. Blend of Western and Asian business cultures. Hierarchy matters.
Quality of life: Excellent food, efficient city, easy Asian travel. But small apartments, humid climate, and political uncertainty.
The Trade-offs
Pros:
- China/Asia access
- Excellent tax efficiency
- Vibrant international city
- Easy regional travel
Cons:
- Extreme housing costs
- Political uncertainty
- Smaller job market than NYC/London
- Limited space and nature
Comparative Analysis
Compensation vs. Cost of Living
| City | Entry IB Total Comp | Rent (1BR) | Tax Rate | Net After Rent |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York | $220K | $48K/year | ~35% | $95K |
| San Francisco | $220K | $42K/year | ~38% | $94K |
| London | $155K | $32K/year | ~32% | $73K |
| Hong Kong | $205K | $44K/year | ~15% | $130K |
Hong Kong's tax advantage creates significant net income differential despite similar gross pay.
Job Market Depth
| City | IB Jobs | PE Jobs | HF Jobs | VC Jobs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York | Deepest | Deepest | Deepest | Strong |
| San Francisco | Moderate | Strong | Moderate | Deepest |
| London | Strong | Strong | Strong | Growing |
| Hong Kong | Moderate | Moderate | Moderate | Limited |
New York dominates overall; San Francisco wins for VC; others have strengths but smaller markets.
Lifestyle Factors
| Factor | New York | San Francisco | London | Hong Kong |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weather | Varies | Excellent | Gray | Hot/humid |
| Space | Small | Moderate | Moderate | Very small |
| Culture/dining | Excellent | Strong | Excellent | Excellent |
| Nature access | Limited | Excellent | Moderate | Moderate |
| Work-life balance | Poor | Moderate | Better | Poor-Moderate |
Career Stage Considerations
Early Career (0-5 Years)
Recommendation: Maximize learning and optionality. New York or London offer broadest experience.
Considerations:
- Build skills in deep market
- Create options for later moves
- Network in concentrated environment
- Don't optimize for lifestyle yet
Mid-Career (5-15 Years)
Recommendation: Consider specialization and lifestyle alignment.
Considerations:
- If tech-focused, San Francisco makes sense
- If Asia-focused, Hong Kong is necessary
- If EMEA-focused, London is optimal
- Lifestyle preferences now matter more
Senior Career (15+ Years)
Recommendation: Align location with long-term priorities.
Considerations:
- Family and personal priorities
- Specific opportunity
- Tax and wealth planning
- Quality of life in later career
Moving Between Cities
Feasibility
| From | To | Difficulty | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| NYC | London | Moderate | Common for EMEA coverage |
| NYC | Hong Kong | Moderate | Requires Asia interest |
| NYC | SF | Easy | Within US, common move |
| London | NYC | Moderate-Hard | Visa challenges for non-US |
| London | HK | Moderate | Common for Asia expansion |
| HK | NYC | Hard | Less common path |
Timing
Best time to move:
- At promotion points (analyst to associate, associate to VP)
- At transition points (new fund, new firm)
- When firm needs staffing in target city
How to position:
- Express interest to management
- Build relationships in target office
- Develop relevant coverage or expertise
Making the Decision
Questions to Ask
Career questions:
- What sector do I want to focus on?
- Where are the best opportunities in that sector?
- What's my 10-year trajectory?
Lifestyle questions:
- What matters for quality of life?
- Where do I want to be long-term?
- What trade-offs am I willing to make?
Practical questions:
- Do I have the right to work there?
- What's my financial situation?
- What are my relationship/family considerations?
Framework
| If you want... | Consider... |
|---|---|
| Maximum optionality | New York |
| Tech/VC focus | San Francisco |
| European lifestyle | London |
| Asia exposure + tax efficiency | Hong Kong |
| Best weather | San Francisco |
| Highest after-tax income | Hong Kong |
| Cultural scene | New York or London |
| Work-life balance | London |
Key Takeaways
Where you build your finance career shapes more than just your job.
New York: Deepest market, highest pay, most intense culture. The default for maximum optionality.
San Francisco: Tech-finance bridge. Best for VC, growth equity, tech coverage. Weather and lifestyle benefits.
London: European hub with better work-life balance. Lower absolute pay but livable lifestyle.
Hong Kong: Asia gateway with tax efficiency. Essential for Greater China focus but uncertain political future.
The honest truth:
There's no objectively best city. The right choice depends on your sector focus, career goals, and lifestyle priorities.
Most finance careers start in one hub and may include time in others. The global nature of finance creates mobility options.
Choose the city that aligns with what you want to build—professionally and personally. You can always move later, but your early career geography shapes your network and trajectory more than you might expect.
Where you start isn't where you finish. But it influences the path.
Related Articles
Dating, Relationships, and Family in Finance: Making Personal Life Work With Demanding Hours
Finance careers are brutal on personal relationships. The hours aren't negotiable. The phone always rings. Plans cancel constantly. Here's how people actually make it work—and when they don't.
Life In FinanceMental Health in Finance: Recognizing Burnout and Building Resilience
The hours are brutal. The pressure is relentless. The culture often ignores the toll. Here's how to recognize when you're struggling—and what actually helps.
Life In FinanceWork-Life Balance in Finance: How Top Performers Actually Make It Work
Work-life balance in finance isn't about working less. It's about strategic energy management, boundary setting, and building a sustainable career. Here's what actually works—not platitudes, but specific tactics.